Moths, grubs, ants and other insects were important sources of energy for indigenous Australians whose traditional bush tucker diet was high in carbohydrates, protein and nutrients, and relatively low in fat and sugars.
Witchetty grubs, for example, were a staple food for many thousands of years and were eaten either raw or roasted. Even I remember finding witchetty grubs with my dad in the bush and cooking them on a griddle (like in this video – which some readers may find disturbing) along with yabbies from the dam.*
The true Central Australian witchetty grubs (Endoxyla leucomochla) live underground and feed on the roots of the ‘witchetty bush’ (See here for a video of locals digging for witchetty grubs and honey ants), but the term is also used for a wide range of stem-boring and root-feeding larvae of cossid and other wood moths and even some beetles.
The idea of marketing these grubs commercially has been around for decades but has not yet taken off.
I remember seeing cans of witchetty grub soup when I was young being sold by Peter Beattie at his paddle steamer restaurant at Swan Hill in northern Victoria. (See here for a nostalgic picture of the label.) Apparently he relied on local schoolchildren to find grubs along the banks of the River Murray.
(See here for a recipe if you want to make your own soup.)
Chef turned farmer, Lynton Manley, preferred to blanch witchetty grubs in boiling salt water before cooking them lightly and serving them on skewers with vegetables at his restaurant on the New South Wales south coast. He was breeding his own witchetty grubs back in the 1980s and discovered first hand some of the challenges:
“They take three years to mature, to thumb-length size, but I am continually stumbling on breeding obstacles such as fungal disease and grubs crawling over each other and puncturing themselves.”
Beattie, Manley and other pioneers of the industry were even exporting grubs back then but reliable supply was, and still is, a problem. (Great distress resulted in 2013 when the ITV reality show ‘I’m a celebrity’ had to cut witchetty grubs from their bush tucker food challenge due to limited supply caused by an unusually wet year.)
A 2006 study examined the feasibility of commercialising witchetty grubs as an Aussie bush food. It included a survey of 1,273 Australians about their perceptions of witchetty grubs:
- Approximately 95% of the sample had heard of witchetty grubs but did not necessarily know anything or much about them.
- Around 10% had eaten a witchetty grub before (2.9% in a restaurant, 8.5% in the wild).
- At least one third would consider ordering witchetty grubs at a restaurant at least once – especially if they were promoted as having a ‘nutty’ or ‘chicken’ taste and/or that they are healthy and nutritious.
- Pan fried witchetty grubs (preferably as an entrée size meal) were more appealing than grubs served in a mornay style sauce or in a salad.
As these grubs take a couple of years to mature in the wild (but can potentially reach full larval size in around twelve months with a controlled environment and appropriate diet), the study recommended that any commercial witchetty grub venture would probably need to be supplemented by other bush food species with shorter life cycles.
For example, bogong moths (Agrotis infusa – not to be confused with ‘bogans’ mentioned in a previous post) could be grown and harvested as well. They are said to have a nutty taste and can be roasted (minus wings and legs) or ground into a powder and then baked in a ‘moth cake’ or pattie.
Bogong moths breed in the pastures west of the Great Dividing Range in Queensland and NSW and feed on nectar from eucalypts, grevilleas and other flowers. They migrate to the Southern Alps for the summer where they shelter in cool alpine caves and dark crevices and rely on their fat reserves to sustain them.
Millions of these large moths pass through Canberra on their way to the high country each year. During this time, you can visit a local Canberra cafe, Ironbark, to try original dishes such as bogong moth frittata served with wattle seed damper and bush tomato chutney.
Bogong moths that are blown off course and end up in Sydney need to watch out for French chef, Jean-Paul Bruneteau, who says that these moths are much better to eat than snails. He recommends removing the wings and roasting them in the oven for three minutes with a splash of canola oil or putting the moths in a coffee blender and sprinkling them into an omelette, pancake or crepe.
Relatively few survivors make the return flight at the end of the summer – as many moths fall prey to spiders, lizards and other reptiles, birds, mountain pygmy possums, marsupial rats and other local wildlife (as well as some humans). After summer their nectar reserves are depleted so moths at this time of the year apparently taste nuttier and less sweet.
Residue found in the moths’ summer refuges indicates high levels of arsenic that may have come from chemicals used by farmers to reduce the crop losses caused by the moths’ cutworm larvae and other pests. Contaminated moths are suspected of poisoning birds and other predators and may be cause for caution in humans who wish to partake of large numbers of this seasonal delicacy. (However, the multiple currawong deaths during the 2003 migration are attributed to a moth eradication program at Parliament House – not arsenic.)
Commercial production can help to control arsenic levels but, as with everything, moderation is still advisable. The high fat content (said to be three times the fat and almost twice the calories of a similar portion of a Big Mac) has led experts to recommend that we eat no more than 10 moths per day. I wonder how many witchetty grubs we can safely consume each day?
See also my previous post about bush tucker plants (here). Lots more to come about bogong moths in Canberra and other insects (here).
Songs about witchetty grubs and bogong moths are few and far between. All credit to Johnny B for this fun song about witchetty grubs (here) filmed in 2011 near Dimboola in western Victoria. I like the comment that ‘No critters were harmed in the making of this video.’
If you are interested in paddle steamers, he also wrote a song called ‘River Boat Man’ (here).
* I ate far more witchetty grub lollies than the real thing. They are not as nutritious but at least there is no chance of them biting your tongue if you choose to eat the head.
- ‘Farmer-chef Digs Up New Yen/dollar Earner‘ by Colin Allison. Sydney Morning Herald online (Published 9 Oct 1986. Accessed 1 March 2014)
- ‘I’m a Celebrity drops witchetty grubs from menu because of national shortage of bushtucker trial favourites’ by Nicola Methven. Mirror Online (15 Nov 2013. Accessed 1 March 2014)
- ‘A Feasibility Study into the Commercialisation of Witchetty Grubs‘. Publication No. 06/109 by B R Rich (Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation 2006)
- ‘Getting a Taste for the Bogong Moth‘ by Kate Rigby in Australian Humanities Review. Issue 50 (ANU Press. May 2011)
- ‘Bogongs migrate south‘ by Abbie Thomas (ABC Science website. Published 14 Nov 2002. Accessed 1 March 2014) This great article includes a recipe for Bogong moth damper.
- ‘Get a taste of bogong moth frittata‘. Sunday Telegraph online (31 Oct 2009. Accessed 1 March 2014)
‘Chuck another bogong on the barbie … or in your sarnie’ by Richard Macey. Sydney Morning Herald online. (Published 5 Oct 2007. Accessed 1 March 2014)
- Soup & packet mix sketches: © Pip Marks (with apologies to Andy Warhol)
- Witchetty grub photo: Sputnikcccp (Wikimedia Commons. Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported license)
- Bogong moth photo: CSIRO Entomology (Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported license)
Categories: Australiana, Biodiversity
Reblogged this on msamba.
There could be many weak-hearted souls who might decide to give them a skip!
Including me if I have a choice!
A good choice for folks on the Paleo Diet, eh? And galactically speaking, Star Trek fans know that Ferengi like their tube-grubs, and Klingons prefer their serpent worms live and squirming. — but I think I’ll pass. Thanks for an interesting post!
I thought the Paleo diet you mentioned was something galactic and kept meaning to look it up. And then I received a newsletter from Susie Burrell (dietician/nutritionist) in my inbox this morning with an article ‘To Paleo or not to Paleo'(http://us2.campaign-archive2.com/?u=bd6f87bca6b24406173a89482&id=4837701d18&e). I had no idea that the hunter gatherer diet was a current fad – What an ideal opportunity for people marketing bush foods! Thanks for the warning re alien cuisine – I will stock up on chocolate space food sticks before undertaking any interplanetary trips.
I just don’t think I could bring myself to eat one, although the lolloes would be ok. However having said that we had some friends in Traralgon, Victoria who were French & they cooked Snails in Garlic Butter for us once when we went for dinner. I was very very reluctant but when I finally tried one it was beautiful. I think I ate more than anyone that night. When I was a kid we used to get what we thought were Witchetty Grubs for fishing. I later found out that they were actually called Wattle Grubs. They look very similar but I never was game to eat one though.
The witchetty bush is a wattle (Acacia) – but the term is used for lots of different grubs. I’m sure they would look scrumptious if you were lost in the bush for a few weeks or if your friend panfried them with some garlic butter!
In that case maybe Wattle Grubs & Witchetty Grubs are the same thing. If hungry enough I’d probably eat anything. So many yucky seeming things it’s more the thought that is off putting than the actual taste.
I actually have the same can of the witchetty grub soup that you have posted about. Very old.
It should be well & truly matured by now!